ADVICE & TIPS, LAYOUTS

Are Kitchen Islands Over? – Outdated Or Timeless Design

Kitchen islands have been a popular design element for many years, yet recently I keep seeing a debate about their current relevance. Are they becoming outdated or out of style? Are kitchen islands over?!

This isn’t a new debate, in fact, the WSJ wrote a piece on it several years ago, it’s just doing the rounds again. (Like most design trends)

In this post, I’ll share my professional opinion and delve into the ongoing appeal of kitchen islands, while also considering when alternative solutions might be more suitable for your kitchen design.

Let’s get into it!

You May Also Like
Kitchen Island Size Calculator Tool – Can You Fit A Kitchen Island?

In a hurry? Here’s my key takeaway:

Are Kitchen Islands Over?… No! 😂

Read on to learn more…

are kitchen islands outdated?

In my opinion, the idea that kitchen islands are becoming obsolete is just not accurate.

In fact, kitchen islands continue to be a highly practical, functional, and aesthetically pleasing feature in many kitchens, especially open concept designs. Their popularity among my clients remains strong, indicating that they are far from being outdated.

However, it’s essential to acknowledge that kitchen islands aren’t a universal solution for every kitchen.

The key to their effectiveness lies in how well they fit into the space and their functionality. A kitchen island needs to complement the kitchen’s layout without causing any spatial constraints.

Interestingly, I am noticing a slight growing trend where some homeowners prefer a dining table instead of a kitchen island, particularly in cases where accommodating both is not feasible due to space limitations.

This shift might suggest a preference for more traditional family kitchen dining spaces in some households but it’s certainly not replacing the concept of the kitchen island.

I think it’s also important to recognize that the trends and styles associated with kitchen islands are subject to change. Over time, certain designs may start to feel outdated as new trends emerge.

Despite this, I believe the fundamental concept of a kitchen island remains timeless.

The functionality and appeal of having a central, versatile workspace in the kitchen are enduring qualities that ensure the kitchen island’s place in home design for the foreseeable future.

Kitchen Island Design Nordiska Kök
Image – Nordiska Kök
A beautiful, practical and functional kitchen island 👍

Are kitchen islands a waste of space?

If done correctly, definitely not!

Kitchen islands offer several significant benefits that enhance both the functionality and aesthetics of a kitchen.

  • Increased Storage: Kitchen islands often come with ample storage space options. Cabinets, drawers, and shelves integrated into the island provide additional space and extra storage options. They also offer more locations for appliances such as dishwashers, under-counter fridges and wine fridges as well as your sink and bins.

  • Social Hub: An island naturally becomes a social focal point in the kitchen. It allows for seating, where family, friends and guests can gather, making it an ideal spot for social interactions. Whether it’s casual dining, a quick coffee break, or engaging in conversation while preparing meals, the island facilitates these social moments.

  • Additional Counter Space: One of the most practical benefits of a kitchen island is the extra counter space and work surface it provides. This space is invaluable for meal prep, cooking, and even as a serving area during gatherings.

  • Aesthetic Centrepiece: Beyond functionality, kitchen islands can significantly enhance the aesthetics of a kitchen. They serve as visual centrepieces that can be customized to complement or contrast the overall kitchen design. Whether through material choice, colour, or design style, islands can be tailored to make a strong design statement.

  • Improved Layout, Flow, and Functionality: The addition of a kitchen island can dramatically improve the overall layout and functionality of a kitchen design. It can create a more efficient work triangle (sink, stove & refrigerator), allowing for a seamless transition between cooking, cleaning, and socializing. The strategic placement of an island can help direct traffic in the kitchen, avoiding congestion and enhancing the overall flow of the space.

You May Also Like
Pros & Cons Of Kitchen Islands – Are They Worth It?

Evolving trends of the kitchen island

As I’ve said, the concept of a kitchen island isn’t ‘over or ‘going away’.

However, the trends and styles of kitchen islands are constantly evolving, and what may be fashionable one year could feel outdated the next.

Here’s my take on some of these changing trends:

  • Waterfall Edges: This style, where the countertop material flows down the sides of the island, has been very popular in recent years. There’s an ongoing debate about whether this trend is still ‘in’ or on its way out, but it continues to be a favourite for many.

  • Seating Style Changes: I think the trend in seating styles at kitchen islands has shifted slightly. Previously, islands with unsupported overhangs were popular. Now, there’s a growing preference for larger, supported overhangs that provide more stable and spacious seating areas.

  • The Double Island Concept: This newer trend is definitely polarizing. It involves having two separate islands in one kitchen. Personally, I’m not a huge fan of this style. It can be quite dividing (literally dividing the room) in terms of opinions on its practicality and aesthetic appeal.

  • Super-Sized Islands or ‘Kitchen Continents’: There’s been a trend towards increasingly larger islands in recent years. I often refer to these large islands as ‘kitchen continents’ due to their substantial size. While they make a bold statement and a good-sized island is definitely beneficial, I question their practicality and functionality, not to mention the significant cost implications.

  • Incorporating Curves: A trend emerging this year is the inclusion of more curves in kitchen designs, with the island being a prime candidate for this style. This can be seen in curved cabinets, countertops, and edge profiles. It’s a refreshing deviation from the straight lines traditionally seen in kitchen designs and adds a unique, modern touch.

While these kitchen trends offer exciting possibilities, it’s important to consider practicality, functionality, and personal style preferences when designing a kitchen island.

Trends may come and go, the key is to find a balance that works for your space and lifestyle!

Kitchen with two islands (double island kitchen design)
Double island concept + waterfall edge on one of the islands

When should you not have a kitchen island?

Deciding against a kitchen island can be a wise choice under certain circumstances. The two biggest reasons I come across as a kitchen designer are:

  1. Space Constraints: The most crucial factor is the available space in your kitchen. If the room is too small, adding an island can make the area feel cramped and restrict movement.

    An island requires sufficient space around it for easy access to cabinets and appliances, and comfortable navigation. In smaller kitchens, an island might compromise the functional flow of the space.

  2. Preference for a Traditional Kitchen Table: Personal preference plays a significant role in this decision. Some people might prefer the classic setup of a dining table over a kitchen island.

    A table can offer a more formal (or informal) dining experience and can be a better fit for the aesthetic or functional needs of certain households.

    If the kitchen cannot accommodate both an island and a dining table (or you don’t have a separate dining room), and you value the traditional dining experience, opting for a table is a sensible choice.

You May Also Like
Kitchen Island Or Kitchen Dining Table – Options Explored

What are some alternatives to kitchen islands?

While kitchen islands are a popular choice, they might not be suitable for every kitchen due to space constraints or personal preferences. Here are some alternatives to having a kitchen island:

  • Traditional Dining Table: A classic dining table is a timeless alternative. It offers a dedicated dining area, fostering a more traditional and formal mealtime environment. Tables come in various sizes and styles, making it easy to find one that fits your kitchen’s aesthetic and space requirements.

  • Kitchen Peninsula: A peninsula is a great alternative that offers similar benefits to an island but is attached to the wall or cabinetry on one end. This makes it a more feasible option for smaller kitchens. Peninsulas provide extra counter space and storage, and can also be used for seating, much like an island.

  • Rolling Cart: For those who need something more flexible, a rolling cart is an excellent choice. It’s a movable solution that can provide additional counter space and storage as needed. When not in use, it can be rolled away to free up space. This is particularly useful in smaller kitchens where every bit of space counts.

U Shape with a peninsula rather than a kitchen island
U-Shape with a peninsula rather than a kitchen island

are kitchen islands over?

The straightforward answer is no – the design concept of kitchen islands is far from being over or out of style.

In fact, kitchen islands remain a highly sought-after feature in many homes, consistently appearing on my clients’ wish lists.

Kitchen islands provide a versatile solution for a variety of kitchen layouts, enhancing both the usability and aesthetics of the space. They offer additional storage and workspace and can serve as a social hub in the kitchen, making them an integral part of modern kitchen design.

It’s important to differentiate between the core concept of a kitchen island and the specific design trends associated with it.

While certain design elements, looks, or styles of kitchen islands may become outdated over time, this is typical of any design trend.

Fashion in kitchen design, like in all aspects of style, tends to be cyclical. Wait long enough and what may seem outdated today will be trendy again in the future! 😊

DISCOVER MORE

Author

Michael from Kitchinsider.com

Michael is a kitchen designer from the UK. He's been designing and project managing new kitchen installations for over 10 years. Before that, he was an electrician and part of a team that fitted kitchens. He created Kitchinsider in early 2019 to help give people advice when it comes to getting a new kitchen.